Politics & Government

Restaurant owner wouldn’t stop talking at Hilton Head meeting. So the mayor walked out

He was speaking to Hilton Head council. Then the mayor and other town leaders walked out

Members of Hilton Head Town Council and Mayor John McCann left the room as a resident addressed them during Tuesday’s council meeting. He was over his time limit, but why did they walk out on Taiwan Scott?
Up Next
Members of Hilton Head Town Council and Mayor John McCann left the room as a resident addressed them during Tuesday’s council meeting. He was over his time limit, but why did they walk out on Taiwan Scott?

When a frustrated — and persistent — Hilton Head resident went over his allotted time to speak at a public meeting on Tuesday, the mayor and three other council members took a bold step.

They got up and walked out.

Taiwan Scott was addressing council about his ongoing fight with the town related to code enforcement issues with his restaurant at 15 Marshland Road. Residents get three minutes to speak, but Scott would not relent.

Mayor John McCann pounded his gavel several times to no avail. He called for the Beaufort County Sheriff’s deputy to remove Scott but the deputy did not immediately respond.

Then, after conferring with Town Manager Steve Riley, McCann called for a two-minute break and left along with council members Bill Harkins, Glenn Stanford and David Ames. Scott continued talking for about another minute before sitting down.

The scene illustrates the tension that sometimes occurs between private citizens and elected officials at official meetings where the public is invited to participate in government business, and the difficult balancing act between showing patience and empathy and losing control of a meeting.

Town code says residents may speak for up to three minutes on any issue — new or old — that concerns the town. When their three minutes are up, a bell-like sound echoes throughout the council chambers.

Typically, speakers start to wrap up their messages. Sometimes they don’t.

What now?

Asked Wednesday about the exchange, McCann said he believed Scott was “showboating.”

“I’m sure (walking out) wasn’t the best option, but we didn’t know what the best option was,” McCann said. “If he signed up again, I would let him speak. But we didn’t want to make it a confrontation.”

Scott, who is a regular presence at council meetings and has spoken before them in the past, said he found McCann’s move “totally disrespectful.”

“They want to suppress the truth,” he said.

Tuesday’s scene was not the only recent dust-up between a citizen and a public board. In December 2015, frequent public critic Skip Hoagland was escorted out of a Bluffton Town Council meeting by two Bluffton police officers on order of Mayor Lisa Sulka after a verbal sparring match with town leaders.

Town leaders are meeting Wednesday to discuss how to address appearances by citizens’ time limits in future meetings, McCann said.

Katherine Kokal moved to South Carolina in 2018 after graduating from the University of Missouri and loves everything about the Lowcountry that isn’t a Palmetto Bug. She has won South Carolina Press Association awards for in-depth and government beat reporting. On the weekends, you can find Kati doing yoga and hiking Pinckney Island.

  Comments