Food & Drink

Sugar Buzz: Double Chocolate Trifle

Make a Double Chocolate Trifle for your next potluck and watch it disappear.
Make a Double Chocolate Trifle for your next potluck and watch it disappear. Drew Martin/The Beaufort Gazette

Editor's note: Sugar Buzz columnist Hannah H. Carroll makes easy dessert recipes, serves them to co-workers and writes about the result.

It's here! Picnic/potluck/barbecue/shindig season has arrived. And I have an easy, crowd-pleasing dessert -- a longtime favorite -- for your next party.

I've been making (read: eating) this Double Chocolate Trifle since high school. My mom had it at a party, got the recipe and started making it for weekly meetings and potlucks. My brother and I were so frequently infuriated when she came home without any leftovers, Mom started setting aside a small portion for us when she made it. (She's a good mom like that.)

I've made this trifle countless times, mostly by request. It's easy and inexpensive to make, and it feeds a crowd. If taking this trifle to a party, use a large, portable bowl with a lid. Be sure to keep it refrigerated just before serving.

Preparation: Can you make brownies? Can you make pudding? That's all there is to it. Note the amount of milk used in the recipe is a cup less than called for on the pudding boxes. This creates a thicker consistency. I don't recommend using a food processor to crush the Heath bars; you want small chunks, not a fine powder.

Taste: The chewiness of the brownies, the creaminess of the pudding and the buttery flavor of the toffee make a satisfying, comforting combination. Whenever I serve this dessert, people rave about it. It's a classic and simple, and sometimes that's all we really want.

The bottom line: People love this dessert. Serve it at a party and you'll come home with an empty dish.

Hannah's rating: 5 stars

Hannah H. Carroll is the assistant features editor for The Island Packet and The Beaufort Gazette, and enjoys making desserts for her family and friends.

Double Chocolate Trifle

13-by-9-inch pan prepared brownies

2 small packages white chocolate JELL-O pudding mix

3 cups milk

1 (8-ounce) tub Cool Whip

3-4 Heath Toffee Bars

Cut brownies into squares.

Combine pudding mix and milk. Whisk until smooth and thick. Gently fold in Cool Whip.

Unwrap Heath bars and put them in a zip-top bag. Crush into small chunks with a mallet or hammer.

Place half the brownies in the bottom of a trifle bowl. Top with half the pudding mixture, then a little less than half the crushed Health bars. Repeat layers, ending with Heath bars on top.

Cover and refrigerate until ready to serve.

Overall rating: 4.5 stars

Straight from the taster's mouth

"I'm a toffee junkie, and the toffee bits at the top made the perfect texture to complement the brownie and pudding filling." Andy Carpenter, copy editor/page designer, 5 stars

"I appreciate that it has both firm (the brownie and Heath Bar) and soft (the pudding and whipped cream) elements. I thought it would be mushy but it's not." Carol Weir, special sections editor, 4.5 stars

"If my husband ever leaves me, this is what I'd make to comfort myself. I would eat it all in one sitting and then start my new life in the morning. Part of me wishes he would just so I could do that." Liz Farrell, the Guide editor, 5 stars

"The big chunks of Heath and brownie make it taste something like a Dairy Queen Blizzard, except substitute pudding for ice cream." Kate Cerve, education reporter, 4 stars

The samplers: 16 employees of The Island Packet and The Beaufort Gazette

The scale:

1 star = Ewww!

5 stars = Seconds, please!

Submit your recipe

Do you have an interesting dessert recipe for Hannah's next experiment? Send it to

Try it at home

Make this Double Chocolate Trifle and tell us what you think at