Beaufort County school board discontinues use of grade floors

tbarton@beaufortgazette.comJuly 2, 2013 

Superintendent Dr. Jeffrey Moss speaks to the members of the Beaufort County school board Tuesday night during the board meeting in Beaufort.

DELAYNA EARLEY — Staff photo Buy Photo

  • The Beaufort County School District has appointed a group of veteran local educators to fill assistant principal positions at 10 district schools.

    They are:

  • Michelle Brockway - a teacher at Hilton Head Island School for the Creative Arts who will become an assistant principal at Hilton Head Island Elementary.

  • Yolanda Goethe - a math coach at Beaufort Middle School who will become an assistant principal at St. Helena Elementary.

  • Matt Hall - a principal intern at Whale Branch Middle School who will become an assistant principal at St. Helena Elementary.

  • Freddie Lawton - an assistant principal at St. Helena Elementary who will become an assistant principal at Whale Branch Middle School.

  • Tara Mack - an assistant principal at St. Helena Elementary who will become an assistant principal at Mossy Oaks Elementary School.

  • Pamela Maddox - an assistant principal at Hilton Head Island Middle School who will become an assistant principal at H.E. McCracken Middle School.

  • Sarah Owen - an assistant principal at Hilton Head Island Elementary who will become an assistant principal at Hilton Head Island Early Childhood Center.

  • Elizabeth Rivera - a teacher at Beaufort Elementary School who will become an assistant principal at Joseph S. Shanklin Elementary School.

  • Steven Schidrich - a principal intern at Bluffton Middle School who will become an assistant principal at the school.

  • Connie Singleton-Murphy - an assistant principal at Whale Branch Middle School who will become an assistant principal at Robert Smalls Middle School.

  • Joseph Warfield - an assistant principal at H.E. McCracken Middle School who will become an assistant principal at Hilton Head Island Middle School.

The school board had this message for students Tuesday night: Beginning in August, what you earn is what you get.

The Beaufort County Board of Education voted unanimously to do away with grade floors, following outcrys from parents and community members and disapproval from the state's top education official.

The board postponed a decision May 21 on the grading practice to give an ad hoc committee more time to study it and review it with newly appointed superintendent Jeffrey Moss.

The practice is used in some or all courses at about a dozen schools in the district.

"I think we should engage students and keep them actively involved during class, and there would not be a need for grade floors," Moss wrote in a May email to a school board member.

He applauded the board's decisions Tuesday, calling the committee's recommendation to end the floors "right on target."

The grading practice, which some say gives struggling students a chance to recover, essentially gives them a higher "F" on a report card. If, for example, a student earns a 45 percent during a quarter, it would show up as a 60 percent. The higher grade prevents the student from falling too far behind and allows another chance to pass before semester grades are issued, principals have said.

Others call it grade inflation and social promotion.

The S.C. Board of Education and state superintendent have frowned on the practice.

State Superintendent Mick Zais, in an April 30 memo, said grade floors "fail to reflect an honest assessment of student mastery of work and the level of completion of a course of study."

County school board members agreed, but member Evva Anderson urged administrators to seek safety-net alternatives for struggling students.

"We still need to provide struggling students a chance to recover and prevent them from falling too far behind to the point where they lose hope and give up," Anderson said, "whether that means remediation or after-school tutoring or something else."

CLOSED SESSION QUESTIONED

The school board also met behind closed doors in apparent violation of state law.

The executive session was called to hear an evaluation from lobbyist Lynn Stokes-Murray of McNair Law Firm and state Sen. Tom-Davis, R-Beaufort, about progress this year in pursuing school finance reform and expanding early childhood education.

Chairman Bill Evans said he called the session because he believed the board would receive legal advice, which is allowed under the state's Freedom of Information Act.

"As it turned out, we received no legal advice," Evans said after the session. "I don't think that's anybody's fault -- probably a misunderstanding on my part about what we were going to hear from them."

Asked why he didn't reconvene in public, Evans said: "It wasn't clear until the end of the meeting that they weren't going to" provide legal advice.

Those who violate the law can be charged with a misdemeanor and face a $100 fine or a 30-day jail term if convicted.

Follow reporter Tom Barton at twitter.com/IPBG_Tom.

Related content:

The Island Packet is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service