Public opposes proposed Beaufort City Council fee for nonprofits, churches, schools, hospital

emoody@beaufortgazette.comJune 11, 2013 

Staff

STAFF

  • In other business, council:

  • Authorized the $320,000 purchase of 1120 Ribaut Road. The land will be used for a small, neighborhood fire station to replace the existing building. Construction is expected to move quickly because the city has about $2.2 million from bond sales that must be used by the summer. Otherwise, the city could face penalties or have to return the money.

  • Gave initial approval to rezoning 1001 Hamar St. for use by Bridges Preparatory School. A second vote is needed.

  • Recognized Sisters Sheila Byrne and Stella Breen from the Franciscan Center for their work in the community.

  • Expressed displeasure that Beaufort County did not approve adding a referendum for a 1-percent local-option sales tax, which city officials hoped would offset revenue decreases.

Beaufort Memorial Hospital's CEO and President Rick Toomey asked the approximately 100 people at Tuesday's Beaufort City Council meeting to stand up if they opposed a property fee on nonprofit groups, churches, schools and hospitals.

Almost everyone rose from the wooden pews.

City Council invited comments on the fiscal year 2014 budget, which will be approved by the end of the month, and residents and nonprofit organizations showed up in force to oppose the proposed fees.

Last month, city staff recommended council levy two new fees to offset an expected budget deficit.

The first is a $40 fee for all vehicles registered in the city, which would be used to pay for street maintenance.

The second is aimed at property owners who don't pay property taxes. Nonprofit groups, churches and schools would pay a public-service fee equal to 0.1 percent of a property's appraised value. The money would be used to support emergency-response services.

"I urge you, do not put a fee on churches and nonprofits," said Colden Battey, chairman of the finance committee for St. Peter's Catholic Church. "These are things that enrich our lives."

A combination of factors -- including the end of a special tax district downtown and an anticipated decrease in property tax value -- has the city grappling with a deficit estimated between $600,000 and $700,000, city manager Scott Dadson said. A more specific number will be available in August when the Beaufort County tax assessor releases results of a reassessment.

Resident Dot Gnann summed it up by saying "I've read your budget not once but twice, and you're in a mess."

"We were told the amount would be small and insignificant to our budget," Beaufort Hospital's Toomey said. "As reimbursement for medical services has decreased, we do not believe any fee is small or insignificant."

Alan Runyan of the Parish Church of St. Helena, and Paul Infinger of the Baptist Church of Beaufort, said fees have a tendency to increase once established.

"Once you get a foot in the door, sometimes its hard to get out," Infinger said.

Dr. Gina Mounfield, interim president of the Technical College of the Lowcountry, argued against the fee. She said education funding is decreasing and the school is already relying more on tuition to cover costs. The school does not need another expense, she said.

Council has not voted on the fees, but the general consensus among members was against the nonprofit fee.

Councilman George O'Kelley Jr. vehemently opposed it during a worksession earlier Tuesday. He and Councilman Mike Sutton suggested other areas of the budget to trim, including their own salaries.

"I just think there are things we can cut before we tax a church," O'Kelley, an active Parish Church member, said. "I will not vote for a budget that will tax a church."

Another work session might be scheduled for Monday to look at ways to trim and adjust the budget before the first vote Tuesday.

Related content

  1. New fees recommended for city of Beaufort car drivers, non-profit organizations, May 15, 2013
  2. Plans heat up for new Mossy Oaks fire station, Jan. 21, 2013

The Island Packet is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service