Port cooperation won't stop conflicts, politics

Published Friday, October 9, 2009
0 comments
Email Article  |  Print Article  |  RSS Feeds  |   Bookmark and Share   |  Search the Archive

tool name

close
tool goes here

Increasing tensions between some Georgia and South Carolina officials over the project to deepen the Savannah River harbor should come as no surprise.

The biggest selling point for a port on the Jasper County side of the river is that it provides a deep-water port much closer to the ocean than the existing Savannah port, making it easier and cheaper to maintain passage for the massive ships expected to come calling after the Panama Canal is widened by 2014.

But if you deepen the Savannah River channel from 42 feet to 48 feet for the 26 miles to the existing port, you decrease the need for another deep-water port.

The Jasper port is a two-state project that would be going nowhere without Georgia's cooperation -- or at least nowhere without an expensive legal battle. The land designated for the port had been owned by the Georgia Department of Transportation to use as a site by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to dump dredge spoil from the river.

But Georgia officials are getting antsy about possible objections to the dredging project from South Carolina officials. The Savannah River Maritime Commission, a state of South Carolina creation, wants to hire a consultant to examine and explain the draft Environmental Impact Statement for the project expected to be released in March.

It's a good idea and one that should be supported financially. It's expected to cost more than $100,000, but it would be money well spent. We must have a full understanding of the impacts of the dredging on this side of the river before the digging begins. That includes possible saltwater intrusion into the Upper Floridan Aquifer, a major drinking water source for the region, and the damage it might cause the Savannah Wildlife Refuge.

A report by the Coastal Environmental Organization of Georgia states that previous dredging projects have reduced the refuge's original 6,000 acres of tidal freshwater marsh to 2,800 acres in 1997. Dredging also has lowered dissolved oxygen levels in the river, causing problems for wildlife and the industries that use the river. And it robs beaches of nourishing sand.

But it should be remembered that the agreement between Gov. Sonny Perdue of Georgia and Gov. Mark Sanford of South Carolina that started the two-state effort to build a port in Jasper County included a provision that South Carolina would help get the Savannah River dredged. That provision was included for a reason: Georgia officials want the harbor deepened, and they don't want South Carolina officials slowing or stopping it.

News this week that the dredging project might need to extend miles into the ocean, greatly increasing its cost, was met with concern from state Sen. Larry Grooms, chairman of the state's Port Oversight Commission and a candidate for governor. Grooms, whose district includes part of Charleston County, has said he worries that South Carolina's help in deepening the river channel to the Garden City Terminal would make the Jasper project unnecessary.

That's always been the case. And the flip side of that -- the Jasper port making it unnecessary to dredge all 26 miles to the Garden City Terminal -- is one of the reasons groups such as the Coastal Conservation League support the Jasper port. That and it takes pressure off expanding the Charleston port.

Concerns about the long-term impacts of the dredging project and of the construction of the Jasper port and accompanying infrastructure should not be dismissed lightly, no matter whether they are self-serving or sincere.

As best we can, let's set aside the politics of the ports and examine the environmental impacts. Residents of both states would have to live with the consequences of either project for a long time to come.

Email Article  |  Print Article  |  RSS Feeds  |   Bookmark and Share   |  Search the Archive

tool name

close
tool goes here

_
_
_

For the latest legislative news from Columbia, visit S.C. Politics today:


Elected Representatives

South Carolina

Nikki Haley, Governor803.734.2100
Jim DeMint, Senator843.727.4525
Lindsey Graham, Senator803.933.0112
Tim Scott, Congressman843.852.2222
Alan Wilson, Attorney General803.734.3970
Joe Wilson, Congressman843.521.2530

Beaufort County

Ed Allen, Coroner843.255.5150
Sharon Burris, Auditor843.255.2500
Doug Henderson, Treasurer843.255.2600
Jerri Ann Roseneau, Clerk of Court843.255.5050
Frank Simon, Probate Judge843.255.5850
Duffie Stone, 14th Jud. Circ. Solicitor843.255.5880
P.J. Tanner, Sheriff843.255.3200

Weston J. Newton, Council Chairman843.706.6111
Paul Sommerville, Vice Chairman843.379.7114
Steven Baer, County Council843.689.3570
Rick Caporale, County Council843.689.9999
Gerald Dawson, County Council843.846.4830
Brian Flewelling, County Council843.379.9805
Herbert Glaze, County Council843.846.2845
William McBride, County Council843.838.2264
Stewart Rodman, County Council843.363.6470
Gerald Stewart, County Council843.705.4753
Laura Von Harten, County Council843.868.1062

City of Beaufort

Billy Keyserling, Mayor843.521.2600
Donnie Ann Beer, City Council843.379.6099
Mike McFee, City Council843.522.1528
George O'Kelley, Jr., City Council843.522.2043
Mike Sutton, City Council843.252.5687

Town of Bluffton

Lisa Sulka, Mayor843.540.1579
Oliver Brown, Town Council843.757.3690
Karen Lavery, Town Council843.384.1442
Ted Huffman, Town Council843.247.8337
Mike Raymond, Town Council843.540.9471

Town of Hilton Head

Drew Laughlin, Mayor843.689.5700
Ken Heitzke, Mayor Pro Tempore843.681.8182
Wm. Lee Edwards, Town Council843.686.9020
Willie Ferguson, Town Council843.686.2863
William D. Harkins, Town Council843.263.3261
Kim Likins, Town Council843.785.4909
George W. Williams, Jr., Town Council843.363.6601

Town of Port Royal

Samuel Murray, Mayor843.524.4890
Vernon DeLoach, Town Council843.524.4655
Mary Beth Grey-Heyward, Town Council843.524.4561
Thomas Klein, Town Council843.522.0068
Joe Lee, Town Council843.522.9867

 

Letters to the Editor

Letter guidelines

Letters to the editor are welcome. Letters must be 250 words or less and signed with your first and last names. Include your street address and daytime telephone number so we can verify the letter before publication. You are limited to one letter per 30 days. Letters may be edited for length, style, grammar, taste and libel. All letters submitted become the property of The Island Packet and The Beaufort Gazette and may be republished in any format. The Packet and the Gazette do not publish endorsement letters on the editorial page. Thank you letters are published in the Monday Lowcountry Life section.

How to reach us

Mail: P.O. Box 5727, Hilton Head Island, SC 29938
Fax: 843-706-3070
Hand-delivered: 10 Buck Island Road, Bluffton or 1556 Salem Road, Beaufort
E-mail: letters@islandpacket.com or letters@beaufortgazette.com.


_